How vehicles are stolen today, and what stops each method
No single product beats every method. This guide lines up the main ways thieves take a vehicle against the protections that answer each one, so you can see where the gaps are.
Mike B., Software Engineer at Scorpion Automotive. Reviewed by James M., Technical Director at Scorpion Automotive.
What stops each way of stealing a vehicle?
Match the protection to the method. A pouch only answers relay theft. A PIN or tag immobiliser answers relay, cloning, OBD programming and CAN injection because the thief cannot supply the second check. A tracker answers none of them, but follows the vehicle afterwards. Parts theft needs physical measures.
Speak to us about layered security
Key facts
- ONS survey data for 2022 to 2023 found signal manipulation of a remote locking device in 40% of vehicle thefts in England and Wales
- Relay, cloning, OBD programming and CAN injection all defeat the factory immobiliser, which trusts the key
- An immobiliser that needs a PIN or tag adds a check the thief cannot copy
- A tracker recovers, it does not prevent
- Using a GPS jammer is an offence under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 2006
The matrix
Read across a row to see which protections answer that method on their own and which only slow the thief or follow the vehicle afterwards.
| Method | Pouch or key box | Steering lock | PIN or tag immobiliser | Tracker with monitoring |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Relay attack on a keyless fob | Yes, while the fob is sealed | Slows the thief | Yes | Follows the vehicle afterwards |
| Key cloning or a new key programmed | No | Slows the thief | Yes | Follows the vehicle afterwards |
| OBD port key programming | No | Slows the thief | Yes | Follows the vehicle afterwards |
| CAN injection through headlight wiring | No | Slows the thief | Yes | Follows the vehicle afterwards |
| GPS or mobile jamming | Not relevant | Not relevant | Not relevant | Jamming-aware units raise an alert |
| Catalytic converter and parts theft | Not relevant | No | No | Does not stop the cut |
'Slows the thief' means a visible lock is a deterrent but can be cut or removed. 'Yes' describes the principle, and depends on a correctly fitted product.
Method by method
Each method has its own post. This is the short version of how it works and what answers it.
-
Relay attack
One device near the house picks up the fob signal and a second device by the car repeats it. A sealed pouch breaks the chain, and an immobiliser that wants a PIN or tag stops a relayed key from driving. See what a relay attack is.
-
Key cloning
A key's electronic identity is copied or a new key is added to the car's list, so the factory immobiliser sees a valid key. Only a second check the cloned key cannot pass helps. See key cloning explained.
-
OBD port programming
A thief gets inside, connects a tool to the diagnostic socket and adds a key. OBD locks slow this down but do not change what the car accepts. See OBD port theft.
-
CAN injection
Dr Ken Tindell's 2023 analysis of a stolen Toyota RAV4 described a device on the headlight wiring sending fake key-valid messages. A key is not involved at all. See CAN injection explained.
-
Jamming
A jammer blocks GPS or mobile signals so a tracker cannot report. Detection is the answer, and the jamming alert is itself a sign of theft. See whether trackers can be jammed.
-
Catalytic converters and parts
A converter can come off in minutes, so prevention means making the vehicle slow and risky to work on. See catalytic converter theft prevention.
Why layers beat a single product
The factory immobiliser asks one question, and four of the six methods answer it falsely.
- Prevent: a CAN bus immobiliser such as the Scorpion X-Series needs a PIN or tag before the vehicle will move. It is not claimed here to hold a Thatcham category.
- Deter: a visible steering lock puts off the opportunist.
- Recover: a monitored tracker, with Scorpion VHF+ as a radio layer in pre-launch, finds what prevention missed.
Our layered security post sets the same idea out for nine vehicle types, and the keyless theft immobilisers page covers the keyless cases in more depth.
Check your own gaps
Answer these about the vehicle you want to protect.
-
Does it have keyless entry or push-button start?
If yes, relay theft is the first concern, and a pouch is a start rather than the answer.
-
Is it a model that thieves target?
Popular vans and high-demand four-by-fours are at the front of the queue for cloning and programming.
-
Does your insurer name a requirement?
Ask which Thatcham category it wants, in writing, then match the product to the wording.
-
What happens if it goes anyway?
If nothing would help find it, add a monitored tracker. The stolen vehicle checklist shows the first hours.
Frequently asked questions
Which theft method is most common?
The ONS survey for 2022 to 2023 found the offender manipulated a remote locking signal in 40% of vehicle thefts in England and Wales. That covers more than relay attacks alone, but it shows how often signals are involved.
Does a Faraday pouch stop all keyless theft?
No. It stops relay attacks on the key inside it. Cloning, OBD programming and CAN injection do not need the fob's radio signal.
Can a steering lock replace an immobiliser?
No, they do different jobs. A lock is a visible deterrent that can be cut, while an immobiliser stops the vehicle starting even if the thief gets in.
Will a tracker stop my vehicle being stolen?
No. A tracker reports where the vehicle is and tells a monitoring centre when it moves. Prevention comes from the immobiliser and the physical layer.
Is it legal for thieves to use jammers?
No. Deliberate interference with radio communications is an offence under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 2006.
Do I need all the protections in the matrix?
Not necessarily. Pick the ones that cover the methods your vehicle is exposed to, and weigh your insurer's wording and the vehicle's value.
Sources
- ONS: Nature of crime, vehicle-related theft (year ending March 2023 tables) (opens in a new tab) (accessed 10 October 2026)
- Dr Ken Tindell, Canis Automotive Labs: CAN Injection, keyless car theft (3 April 2023) (opens in a new tab) (accessed 10 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Wireless Telegraphy Act 2006, section 68, deliberate interference (opens in a new tab) (accessed 10 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Scrap Metal Dealers Act 2013, section 12 (opens in a new tab) (accessed 10 October 2026)
Related pages
- Keyless theft immobilisers Relay, clone and CAN injection answered in one page.
- Which vehicle security do you need? Alarm, immobiliser or tracker first, for nine vehicle types.
- How to protect a keyless car Habits and hardware for push-button vehicles.
- Car immobiliser buyer's guide Five immobiliser types and a quote checklist.
Want the gaps in your vehicle's protection closed?
Tell us the vehicle and what your insurer asks for, and we will say which layers fit.