Skip to main content
English
Thatcham and Insurance

Thatcham Approved vs Non-Thatcham Alarms: Does It Matter?

6 min read

By Ian D. Reviewed byJames M.

Thatcham Approved vs Non-Thatcham Alarms: Does It Matter?: Scorpion Automotive guide illustration with an alarm siren icon

A Thatcham approved alarm matters most when your insurer names a Thatcham category as a condition of cover. Then it’s not optional. Beyond insurance, Thatcham approval is independent proof that the alarm has been tested to a published standard. A non-Thatcham alarm can still be the right choice where no category is required and budget or features come first.

The short answer:

  • Insurer asks for a category? Fit one that meets it, installed and certificated properly.
  • High-value or high-risk vehicle? A Thatcham alarm is the safer default.
  • No requirement and a modest car? A good non-Thatcham alarm still deters and alerts.
  • Keyless car? Whichever alarm you choose, think about an immobiliser that resists relay theft too.

What does Thatcham approval mean?

Thatcham Research is the UK motor insurers’ research centre. It was founded in 1969, is funded by the insurance industry and tests vehicle security products against its own published requirements. Products that pass are assigned a category, and insurers use those categories as shorthand when they set security conditions.

For alarms and immobilisers, the categories that come up most are these (Motoring Research):

  • Category 1: an electronic immobiliser and an integrated alarm, with sensors, a back-up power supply and a siren.
  • Category 2: an immobiliser on its own, which must limit at least two separate circuits and set itself automatically.
  • Category 2-1: an alarm added to a vehicle that already has a Category 2 immobiliser, which brings it up to Category 1 status.

Tracking has its own categories, S5 and S7. Our What is Thatcham? guide covers all of them.

When does a Thatcham alarm really matter?

When your insurer names a category

This is the big one. On some vehicles, insurers make a particular Thatcham category a condition of cover. If the policy says Category 1 and you fit a non-Thatcham alarm, the condition hasn’t been met. That can leave you uninsured for theft, which is a far bigger cost than the price difference between two alarms.

Read the exact wording. Insurers don’t always ask for an alarm. Some ask for an immobiliser, others for a tracker. Our explainer on Thatcham Category 1 vs Category 2 helps translate the requirement.

When you want independent proof

Not every buyer has an insurance condition to meet. Some simply want reassurance that the product has been tested by someone other than the maker. Thatcham approval gives that.

When the installation needs to be recognised

Approval covers the product. The fitting matters too. Thatcham launched its Thatcham Recognised Installer scheme in 2010, with conditions including product training and Police National Computer checks for installers (The Auto Channel). For a Thatcham-category alarm, keep the installation certificate safe. Your insurer may ask for it.

When is a non-Thatcham alarm a sensible choice?

There’s nothing second-rate about a well-made non-Thatcham alarm. It’s simply not been put through the approval process for a category.

It can be the right call when:

  • your insurer hasn’t asked for a Thatcham category
  • the vehicle is modest in value and the main aim is deterrence
  • you want specific features, such as extra remotes or using the car’s original fob, at a lower cost
  • the vehicle is older or unusual and the main need is an audible alarm and an immobiliser circuit

Scorpion makes both. In the S-Series alarm range, the S4 is a non-Thatcham remote alarm with a CDL immobiliser and two additional radio keys, and the S12 is a non-Thatcham upgrade alarm that uses the original vehicle remote. Both give perimeter and ultrasonic interior protection.

Thatcham and non-Thatcham compared

QuestionThatcham approved alarmNon-Thatcham alarm
Meets an insurer’s category conditionYes, at its categoryNo
Independently tested to a published standardYesNot by Thatcham
Perimeter and interior protectionYesUsually, check the spec
Battery-backed sirenRequired for Category 1Varies by model
Typical buyerHigher-value cars, insurer conditions, motorhomesBudget-conscious owners, no insurer requirement

Which Scorpion alarms are Thatcham approved?

ModelStatusNotes
S30Thatcham Category 1Remote alarm immobiliser with keypad programmer and override
S32Thatcham Category 2-1Plip upgrade using the original vehicle remote
S34Thatcham Category 2-1Plip upgrade with additional radio keys, suits motorhomes
S37Thatcham Category 2-1CAN bus upgrade with RF receiver for wireless PIR sensors
S4Non-ThatchamRemote alarm with CDL immobiliser
S12Non-ThatchamUpgrade alarm using the original vehicle remote

If you’re new to the parts that make up an alarm, start with how a car alarm works.

Does a Thatcham alarm stop keyless theft?

An alarm reacts to a break-in. Relay theft often doesn’t look like a break-in: the doors open with what the car thinks is the real key, and a plip upgrade alarm that follows the car’s own locking sees what looks like normal use.

That doesn’t make the alarm pointless. It does mean that on a keyless car, the alarm should be paired with an immobiliser that needs a PIN or tag the thief can’t copy.

Tracking and a radio layer on top

Higher-value vehicles often pair an alarm with an S5 or S7 tracker. Scorpion’s Scorpion VHF+ Recovery Network is in pre-launch and would sit beneath that tracker, so check with your insurer before treating it as a policy condition. The UK VHF tracker options page compares the choices.

Ask us whether your vehicle needs a Thatcham alarm

Got an insurer requirement to meet, or not sure whether you need a Thatcham alarm at all? Tell us the vehicle and the policy wording.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. There is no law requiring a Thatcham alarm. It becomes a requirement only when an insurer makes a Thatcham category a condition of cover, which some do on higher-value or higher-risk vehicles.

Will a Thatcham approved alarm lower my insurance?

It may. Insurers treat Thatcham-approved security as independently proven, and some reflect that in premiums. The effect depends on your insurer, vehicle and policy, so ask them directly.

What is the difference between Category 1 and Category 2-1?

Category 1 is a complete alarm and immobiliser system. Category 2-1 is an alarm added to a car that already has a Category 2 immobiliser, which together reach Category 1 status.

Do I need a certificate for a Thatcham alarm?

Keep the installation certificate for any Thatcham-category alarm. It shows what was fitted and when, and your insurer may ask to see it.

Are non-Thatcham alarms any good?

A well-made non-Thatcham alarm still deters thieves and raises the alarm. It just hasn’t been approved to a Thatcham category, so it won’t meet an insurer condition that names one.

Speak to our team

Questions about vehicle security, tracking or fleet telematics? Our UK team will point you to the right product for your vehicle or fleet.

View all products →
Tags:
  • Thatcham
  • car alarms
  • insurance
  • S-Series
  • VHF+
Scorpion Automotive

Ian D.

Head of R&D at Scorpion Automotive

Ian D. is Head of R&D at Scorpion Automotive in Chorley and writes about Thatcham, insurance and OEM engineering.

Reviewed by James M., Technical Director at Scorpion Automotive