Are Car Alarms Worth It Against Modern Car Theft?
By Mike B. Reviewed byJames M.
Are car alarms worth it? Yes, for most vehicles, but not as the only line of defence. A car alarm still deters opportunists, protects what’s inside and meets many insurers’ conditions. Against keyless relay theft it can be bypassed, so pair it with an immobiliser that needs a PIN and, on valuable vehicles, a tracker.
The short answer:
- Worth it for contents: an alarm notices a smashed window and a hand reaching in.
- Worth it for deterrence: a flashing LED and a siren push opportunists to another car.
- Worth it for insurance: some policies require a Thatcham-rated alarm.
- Not enough alone against keyless theft: a relayed key can look like the owner.
- Best as one layer alongside an immobiliser and a tracker.
Do car alarms still deter thieves?
They deter the thieves who rely on time and quiet. That’s still a large group: the person trying door handles in a car park, or breaking a window for a bag on the seat.
What deters them:
- The LED. A visible, flashing light says “this one will make noise” before anyone touches the car.
- The siren. Once it sounds, every extra second at the car is a bigger risk for the thief.
- Indicator flashes. They pinpoint which car is being tampered with.
Car alarms are so common that people sometimes ignore them. That’s fair. But the deterrent works on the thief’s decision, not the passer-by’s. Most opportunists won’t gamble that nobody will look.
What can’t a car alarm do?
An alarm detects and warns. It doesn’t stop an engine starting, and it doesn’t find a car once it’s gone.
Its limits show most on keyless cars. In a relay attack, thieves extend the signal from the real key so the car opens and starts as if the owner were standing beside it. ONS crime survey tables for England and Wales, covering the year ending March 2023, show the offender had manipulated a remote locking signal in 40% of vehicle thefts (ONS).
If the car believes the key is present, an alarm that follows the car’s own locking sees normal use. It may never sound. That’s why an alarm on its own isn’t the answer to keyless theft. Our guide to keyless theft and immobilisers covers what does stop it.
An alarm can’t follow a car that has gone. That job belongs to tracking, and the VHF+ network we’re building pairs a radio beacon with whatever tracker is already fitted for the close-range end of a search.
When is a car alarm definitely worth it?
Some situations make the case clear.
| Situation | Why an alarm earns its place |
|---|---|
| Your insurer names a Thatcham alarm category | It’s a condition of cover, so it isn’t optional |
| You carry tools, stock or equipment | It protects the contents, which are often the real target |
| You own a motorhome or van | Living areas, lockers and load spaces need watching |
| You park on the street or in public car parks | Opportunist break-ins are the main risk |
| The car is older without strong factory security | An alarm with immobiliser circuits adds real protection |
In the Thatcham scheme, a Category 1 system combines an electronic immobiliser with an integrated alarm, while Category 2-1 adds an aftermarket alarm to a car that already has a Category 2 immobiliser (Motoring Research). If your policy names either, the alarm is required.
Should you get an alarm or an immobiliser?
If you can only choose one, choose by risk.
- Break-ins for contents point to an alarm.
- Drive-away theft of a keyless car points to an immobiliser that asks for a PIN or tag.
Most owners don’t have to choose. The two cover different moments in a theft, and they work together. We compare them directly in car alarm vs immobiliser.
What’s the best way to use a car alarm today?
Treat the alarm as one layer of three:
- Alarm for detection, deterrence and contents.
- Immobiliser for stopping the drive-away, including relay theft.
- Tracker for getting the vehicle back if the first two are beaten.
Scorpion makes each layer. The alarms and immobilisers range covers the S-Series alarms and the X-Series CAN bus immobiliser. Scorpion Defender combines a ScorpionTrack tracker with an alarm. When the alarm triggers, it sounds and notifies the owner by app, email or SMS, and the tracker takes over if the vehicle moves. Defender X adds the X-Series immobiliser for all three.
Talk to us about choosing an alarm
Wondering whether an alarm, an immobiliser or a full Defender bundle suits your vehicle? Tell us what you drive and where it’s kept.
- Speak to us for a straight answer
- Scorpion Defender for layered protection
Frequently Asked Questions
Do car alarms actually stop theft?
They stop some theft, mainly opportunist break-ins and attempts that rely on time and quiet. They don’t stop a car being driven away by thieves who have, or have relayed, the key. For that, add an immobiliser.
Do people ignore car alarms?
Passers-by sometimes do. The deterrent still works on thieves, who can’t be sure nobody will look. A flashing LED also makes many opportunists pick a different car before they start.
Is a car alarm worth it on a keyless car?
Yes for the contents and deterrence, but it isn’t enough on its own. Relay attacks can open a keyless car as though the owner were present. Pair the alarm with a PIN or tag immobiliser.
Is a car alarm or a tracker better?
They do different jobs. An alarm deters and protects contents. A tracker helps recover the vehicle after a theft. On higher-value vehicles, the strongest set-up uses both, plus an immobiliser.
Does a car alarm reduce insurance?
It may, especially a Thatcham-rated one, but it depends on the insurer and the vehicle. Some insurers require an alarm as a condition of cover rather than offering a discount. Ask yours directly.
Speak to our team
Questions about vehicle security, tracking or fleet telematics? Our UK team will point you to the right product for your vehicle or fleet.
Related Products
View all products →- car alarms
- keyless theft
- Defender
- VHF+
Mike B.
Software Engineer at Scorpion Automotive
Mike B. is a Software Engineer at Scorpion Automotive in Chorley. Vehicle security, immobilisers and keyless theft are the areas Mike covers.
Reviewed by James M., Technical Director at Scorpion Automotive