Car Immobiliser with Fob or Keyless PIN: Which Is Right?
By Mike B. Reviewed byJames M.
A car immobiliser with a fob arms and disarms from a remote, usually alongside an alarm. It’s convenient, but a fob can be lost, stolen in a burglary or targeted by signal attacks. A keyless PIN immobiliser asks for a code on the car’s own buttons instead, so there’s nothing for a thief to take or relay.
The short version:
- Fob immobiliser: armed and disarmed by a remote, often part of an alarm system.
- Driver tag immobiliser: releases when a separate tag you carry is in the car.
- PIN immobiliser: needs a code on the car’s buttons or a keypad, with nothing to carry.
- Against relay and cloning: tags and PINs give a second check the car key can’t supply.
- Many owners combine an alarm with fobs and a hidden PIN or tag immobiliser.
What is a car immobiliser with a fob?
A fob immobiliser is controlled by a small radio remote. Press the button and the system arms or disarms. Many aftermarket alarms include an immobiliser and come with their own remotes, or use the car’s original remote.
Scorpion’s S-Series alarms show the range of options:
- S4: a non-Thatcham alarm and immobiliser with two additional radio keys.
- S12: a non-Thatcham upgrade alarm that uses the car’s original radio keys.
- S30: a Thatcham Category 1 alarm and immobiliser with a keypad programmer and override.
- S34: a Thatcham Category 2 to 1 upgrade alarm with additional radio keys.
See the full range of S-Series alarms for the rest of the line-up.
What are the pros and cons of a fob?
A fob is familiar. You already use one to lock the car, so arming the security with a button press feels natural.
The downsides come from the fob being a physical thing:
- It can be lost, leaving you relying on an override.
- It can be stolen with your keys in a burglary.
- It’s another radio device, and radio is what keyless thieves attack.
- It depends on the battery, which needs replacing from time to time.
None of this makes a fob a bad choice. It means the fob shouldn’t be the only thing standing between a thief and a drive-away.
How does a keyless PIN immobiliser compare?
A keyless PIN immobiliser removes the extra device altogether. The X-Series immobiliser is a CAN bus immobiliser that arms itself when the ignition goes off. To drive, you enter a custom PIN using a sequence of the car’s own buttons, via the dash or steering wheel.
There’s no fob to lose, nothing for a burglar to pick up and no extra signal to capture. If a thief relays your car key or programs a new one, the car opens but won’t be driven away.
| Fob immobiliser | Driver tag | Keyless PIN (CAN) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you carry | A remote | A small tag | Nothing |
| Arms automatically | Depends on system | Yes | Yes |
| Taken in a burglary | Possible | Possible if kept with keys | No |
| Extra radio device | Yes | Yes | No |
| Visible to a thief | Often | No | No |
| Daily effort | Press a button | None | Enter a code |
Should you choose a fob, a tag or a PIN?
Choose by how you use the car and what worries you most.
- Mainly want an alarm? A fob-controlled alarm and immobiliser gives sirens, sensors and simple control.
- Worried about keyless theft? Add a hidden PIN or tag immobiliser, because it asks for something the car key can’t provide.
- Want convenience every day? A driver tag removes the code entry. Our guide to driver tag vs PIN compares the two in depth.
- Insurer asked for a category? Check the wording first. Thatcham categories apply to specific approved products, so match the product to the requirement.
The X-Series supports both PIN and tag. Paired with a ScorpionTrack S5, a driver tag disarms the immobiliser automatically as you get in, and the PIN stays available as a backup.
Can you have an alarm with a fob and a PIN immobiliser together?
Yes, and for keyless cars it’s a strong combination. The alarm deals with forced entry and draws attention. The hidden immobiliser deals with the drive-away.
Scorpion Defender X shows how far this can go. It combines a ScorpionTrack S5 tracker, a Scorpion alarm and the X-Series CAN bus immobiliser in one package. Our alarms and immobilisers range covers the alarm side for cars, vans and 24V trucks.
Talk to us about fob immobilisers
Deciding between a fob, a tag or a PIN? Tell us your car and what you want the security to do.
- Speak to us about the right immobiliser for your car
- X-Series immobiliser for keyless PIN and driver tag protection
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a car immobiliser with a fob?
It’s an immobiliser armed and disarmed with a radio remote, usually as part of an alarm system. Some use extra remotes supplied with the alarm, others use the car’s original remote to control it.
Is a fob or a PIN immobiliser better?
A fob is quick and familiar. A PIN immobiliser has nothing to lose or steal and no extra radio signal. For keyless cars, a hidden PIN or tag immobiliser adds the second check that stops relay and cloned-key theft.
Can a thief copy an immobiliser fob?
Any radio device is a potential target. That’s why many owners add an immobiliser that needs a PIN entered on the car’s own buttons, which can’t be copied from a signal or taken in a burglary.
Does the Scorpion X-Series come with a fob?
No. The X-Series is disarmed by a custom PIN entered on the car’s own buttons, or by a driver tag when paired with a ScorpionTrack S5. There’s no remote fob to relay or lose.
Can I add a PIN immobiliser to a car with an alarm?
Yes. A hidden CAN bus immobiliser works alongside an alarm. The alarm reacts to forced entry, and the immobiliser stops the car being driven without the PIN or tag.
Speak to our team
Questions about vehicle security, tracking or fleet telematics? Our UK team will point you to the right product for your vehicle or fleet.
Related Products
View all products →- immobilisers
- key fob
- car alarms
- X-Series
- VHF+
Mike B.
Software Engineer at Scorpion Automotive
Mike B. is a Software Engineer at Scorpion Automotive in Chorley. Vehicle security, immobilisers and keyless theft are the areas Mike covers.
Reviewed by James M., Technical Director at Scorpion Automotive