How to compare tracker recovery rates
A percentage recovered tells you nothing until you know what was counted, over what period and who made the recovery. Here is how to read the claim before you trust it.
Morgan P., Head of Tracking Support at Scorpion Automotive. Reviewed by James M., Technical Director at Scorpion Automotive.
How do you compare stolen vehicle recovery rates?
You mostly cannot, because each provider defines its own rate. Ask what the denominator is, what period it covers, who made the recovery and whether anyone audited it. A figure with none of those answers is a marketing claim, whatever the percentage.
Key facts
- Providers publish rates, values, counts and times, and these measure different things
- A rate with no stated base or period cannot be compared with another provider's
- A fastest-recovery time is a best case, not a typical one
- Scorpion publishes monthly recovered values and fastest times, and no percentage rate
- National police data on stolen vehicles is shared with six named tracking providers
Five ways a recovery claim gets built
The same theft can feed five different headline numbers. Each one answers a different question, and none of them answers all of them.
| Claim type | What it counts | What to ask | How it can mislead |
|---|---|---|---|
| A percentage recovered | Vehicles found, divided by some total | Which total: all thefts reported, or only certain fitted units? | A different denominator changes the figure without changing the service |
| A value recovered | Pounds or euros of vehicles returned | Over which period, and counted at what value per vehicle? | A few high-value cars lift the total, and it grows with the customer base |
| A count of vehicles | How many were found | How many were fitted over the same period? | A larger fleet finds more vehicles without finding a larger share |
| A time to recover | Minutes or hours from report to recovery | Is this the fastest case, the median, or a share within a window? | The quickest recovery of a month says little about the slowest |
| Who recovered it | Police, the provider's team or the owner | How many needed police, and how many were found by the owner? | A recovery by the owner counts the same as a coordinated one |
Treat any single number as one view of the service. A provider that shows several, with definitions, is easier to hold to account.
Six questions to put to any recovery claim
Ask them in this order. If the first has no answer, the rest hardly matter.
-
What is the base?
Ask for the total the percentage is taken from. All vehicles reported stolen, or only those where the unit kept transmitting, give very different results.
-
Which period does it cover?
A year, a quarter or one good month are different claims. Ask for the dates, and whether older thefts that are still open are included.
-
What counts as recovered?
Found intact, found stripped, found abroad and located but not returned are different outcomes. Ask which of them the provider counts.
-
Who checked it?
An audit by a third party carries weight. A figure with no source line beside it is the company's own statement, and you should read it that way.
-
Who made the recovery?
Most recoveries involve the police at the final step. Ask how often the provider's control room, rather than a patrol car, located the vehicle.
-
Does it match your vehicle?
A rate built mostly on cars says little about a motorcycle, a van or a plant machine. Ask for the split.
Claims in the market, set beside what is missing
These are the providers' own published figures, quoted so you can see what each one leaves out. Listing a claim is not a ranking, and none of these has been audited by Scorpion.
| Provider and claim | Where published | Not stated beside it | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tracker: a 95% recovery success rate, with 50% of recoveries within 4 hours and 80% within 24 hours | Tracker's own website | The base and the period | 3 October 2026 |
| LoJack Italia: an 80% recovery rate for 2025, against a national figure of 40 to 45% | LoJack's figures as reported by Auto.it | A published base or an independent audit | 3 October 2026 |
Each figure is the provider's own statement. See our Scorpion and Tracker comparison and the LoJack comparison for the wider picture, and check each source yourself before relying on it.
What Scorpion publishes, and what it does not
Scorpion Automotive Group reports recovery results every month, combining Datatool motorcycles and scooters with ScorpionTrack cars and vans.
- June 2026: £492,800 of stolen vehicles recovered. The June post gives a fastest recovery of 10 minutes.
- July 2026: £828,100 recovered, made up of £396,750 by Datatool and £431,350 by ScorpionTrack. The July post records a fastest recovery of 6 minutes.
- August 2026: £754,125 recovered, and a 2026 running total of £5.8 million. The August post gives a fastest recovery of 9 minutes.
- No percentage rate: this site does not publish one, so there is no figure here to set against the claims above.
Those are values and fastest times, which answer a narrower question than a rate does. The value rises with the number of customers, and the fastest time is the best case of the month, so neither should be read as a typical result.
Scorpion VHF+ is still in pre-launch and has no recovery results yet, so it does not appear in any of the figures above.
Why the police role changes how you read a claim
A recovery usually finishes with an officer, so the police arrangement behind a provider matters.
- The National Police Chiefs' Council said, in FOI response 2994/2026 dated 30 June 2026, that the National Vehicle Crime Intelligence Service shares stolen vehicle details with six named tracking providers.
- The same answer said there is no exclusivity, and each force decides which provider it works with.
- Police VHF detection kit is far from universal. Across the 15 forces that gave numbers, 177 of 9,557 vehicles (1.85%) carry it, as set out in our UK Police VHF Readiness Report.
The practical reading: a radio-based recovery depends on police equipment in range, and a GPS-led one depends on a control room reaching the right force quickly. Ask any provider which of those it relies on, and for evidence of how often each happens.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good stolen vehicle recovery rate?
There is no agreed benchmark, because providers count different things over different periods. A high percentage with a stated base, period and definition is more useful than a higher one with none.
Is a higher recovery percentage always better?
No. A percentage depends on its denominator. A provider that counts only vehicles whose unit kept transmitting will report a higher rate than one counting every reported theft.
Does Scorpion publish a recovery percentage?
Not on this site. It publishes the monthly value of vehicles recovered and the fastest recovery. A percentage would need its base and definition printed beside it, in the way this guide asks of every other provider.
Does the police recover most stolen tracked vehicles?
Police are usually involved at the final step, because an officer has to take the vehicle back. How the vehicle is located first varies, and a provider can tell you how often its own control room did that.
Do competitors' recovery claims count as proof?
They count as claims. Treat a figure as proof only when it states what it counted, over which period, and who checked it.
Sources
- Tracker: home page (recovery figures as reported by Tracker) (opens in a new tab) (accessed 3 October 2026)
- Auto.it: LoJack 2025 recoveries in Italy (LoJack's figures) (opens in a new tab) (accessed 3 October 2026)
- Scorpion Automotive: UK Police VHF Readiness Report (FOI answers including NPCC 2994/2026) (opens in a new tab) (accessed 3 October 2026)
- Scorpion Automotive: monthly recovery statistics, June to August 2026 (opens in a new tab) (accessed 10 October 2026)
Related pages
- Scorpion VHF+ Recovery Network The radio recovery layer, in pre-launch.
- UK Police VHF Readiness Report What UK forces told us about VHF receivers.
- What the NPCC's FOI answer says Police data sharing and the claim of exclusivity.
- Police VHF receivers by force Receiver numbers behind the FOI figures.
- August 2026 recovery statistics The most recent monthly figures.
Comparing recovery for a fleet or an insurer scheme?
Tell us the vehicles and what the claims should prove, and we will point you to the recovery figures that fit.